Skip to content
SignHR
All templates
Recruitment

Candidate Evaluation Scorecard

A weighted interview scorecard for consistent candidate evaluation across technical skills, problem-solving, communication, culture fit, and leadership.

CANDIDATE EVALUATION SCORECARD Position: [Role Title] Candidate Name: [Full Name] Interview Stage: [Phone Screen / Technical Round / Culture Fit / Final Round] Interviewer Name: [Name] Interview Date: [DD/MM/YYYY] SCORING GUIDE 5 — Outstanding: Significantly exceeds expectations. 4 — Exceeds Expectations: Consistently above the bar for this role. 3 — Meets Expectations: Solid capability. Exactly what we are looking for. 2 — Below Expectations: Partially meets requirements. Notable concerns. 1 — Poor: Does not meet minimum requirements. N/O — Not Observed 1. Technical / Functional Skills (Weight: 30%) Score: ___ / 5 Strong Evidence: [Specific examples, projects, or responses] Concerns / Red Flags: [Gaps, incorrect claims, or lack of depth] Overall Notes: [Summary assessment] 2. Problem Solving & Critical Thinking (Weight: 20%) Score: ___ / 5 Strong Evidence: [Examples from case studies, technical challenges, or behavioural questions] Concerns / Red Flags: [Overly rigid thinking, inability to handle complexity] Overall Notes: [Summary assessment] 3. Communication & Collaboration (Weight: 15%) Score: ___ / 5 Strong Evidence: [Clear explanations, teaching concepts, cross-team collaboration] Concerns / Red Flags: [Poor listening, overly vague, difficulty explaining concepts] Overall Notes: [Summary assessment] 4. Cultural Fit & Values Alignment (Weight: 15%) Score: ___ / 5 Strong Evidence: [Responses to culture-fit questions, attitude, enthusiasm] Concerns / Red Flags: [Values misalignment, negative attitude, defensiveness] Overall Notes: [Summary assessment] 5. Leadership & Initiative (Weight: 10%) Score: ___ / 5 Strong Evidence: [Leading projects, initiating improvements, mentoring peers] Concerns / Red Flags: [Lack of proactivity, blame-shifting, disengagement] Overall Notes: [Summary assessment] 6. Growth Potential (Weight: 10%) Score: ___ / 5 Strong Evidence: [Learning agility examples, feedback incorporation, career goals] Concerns / Red Flags: [Fixed mindset, entitlement, lack of self-awareness] Overall Notes: [Summary assessment] OVERALL EVALUATION Total Raw Score: ___ / 30 | Weighted Score: ___ / 5.0 HIRE RECOMMENDATION ☐ Strong Hire — Proceed without hesitation. ☐ Hire — Meets overall bar. Minor development areas. ☐ Lean Hire — Some reservations but net positive. ☐ No Hire — Does not meet the bar. ☐ Strong No Hire — Significant concerns. Top 3 Strengths: 1. [Strength] | 2. [Strength] | 3. [Strength] Top 3 Development Areas: 1. [Area] | 2. [Area] | 3. [Area] Additional comments for hiring committee: [Provide a balanced summary with standout moments and notable concerns.] Interviewer Signature: _______________________ Date: _______________________

Run your next payroll on SignHR.

See it with your own policies in a 30-minute demo, or set up your workspace yourself today.

Pricing